Thread: American Idol

Looks like Brooke or Jason might be in trouble....

I actually thought Jason't first song was good. That was first for me. This should have been a good night for him since that type of music fist him but nope.

Brook was not good on the first and OK on the second.
David C. good as always
David A. good as always
Saysha - first one was good second one better. She def. would fit in on broadway type where she can show some personality

And what was up w/ Paula talking about Jason's second performance that hadn't taken place. She then tried to say it was about David C. but she had just said it left her feeling "empty". but loved David C. What is that girl on?!?!

Each week I like David A. less and less...He always sounds the SAME, no matter what he is singing...He kinda makes me sick,lol....I know I am mostly alone, but I cant stand him any longer...YUCK..lol
I love David C. he is awesome! and unpredictable
Brookes first song was awful, but I really liked her second performance...she needs to stick with the piano.. (she is obviously not the american idol)
Syesha should be on broadway, she likes to act and she loves the lime light..I think she is trying to get noticed, because she seems to realize she is not the American Idol. I thought both of her performances were good, in the musical sort of way...
Now Jason, I think he should have left last week, I like his singing, BUT he also has been sounding the same...
If I could pick, I would tell David A. to go home, did you know I dont like him? lol
jmo

Originally Posted by ladybugmo

And what was up w/ Paula talking about Jason's second performance that hadn't taken place. She then tried to say it was about David C. but she had just said it left her feeling "empty". but loved David C. What is that girl on?!?!

WOW, wasnt that pathetic? She has been known to take a few drinks now and then.....maybe she was putting whiskey in her coke last night,lol...Since it was so hard last night,lol...


Madie I really think Paula was drinking or something, I dont think it was "pre-determined"......but that is just my opinion.....Most of the time, to me, she seems to be on something,lol....

http://tv.msn.com/tv/article.aspx?news=311840&GT1=7703
Article about Paula

bubbles David A. is not my top pick either. I like Brook behind the pian that his her element.

I have known several people like Paula, they are just a little off balance. I, personally, love Paula.

I hated to see Brooke go, but I kinda figured it would be her....I loved her personality and when she was behind the piano....She will definately go on to do greater things than American Idol...
Honestly, I think it would be better not to be the winner, then maybe they could have a little control with their music...
I am sure it will be between the two Davids, David C is my fav....but I figure David A will win....I guess we will see...