Thread: American Idol

Remember the girl who told Simon she could blow his socks off? I don't think she meant it ugly but what did she mean by that? I was surprised more wasn't said about that.
I love the kid with the dreads but I hate the hair. It's gotta go! Surely it will before the show ends.
I don't like the arm tattoo but I like her singing ok. When it shows her family it shows a man covered in tattoos. Guess that is her husband?
David with the pushy father can go anytime. I think he has a beautiful voice but he just isn't right for so many kinds of songs. He seems like he ought to be singing opera or something.
I don't think they have anyone who stands out like the years past. There is not a one of them that would upset me to see him/her go.
I too like rock and they just haven't had enough of it. My favorite of all the past winners is Taylor Hicks. I also like some of Rubin's singing. But I haven't seem much of either of them since they won. I also like Clay's singing. I think if they voted again his chance of winning could be better than Rubins. There truly was a phone problem. My sil worked in NC for the phone company at the time of that voting.

So who do you want to go home tonight??? I thought Mariah Carey songs was not a good choice...

Well I just KNEW they would do that at the end with David Cook and I wasn't surprised at the bottom 3. I do think Jason needs to be out though, he is just getting weaker it seems while both the Davids and Carly just do great.
Christy Lee will be making records just like Kelly Pickler soon.

weird I replied to this earlier this morning but my reply isn't here well here it is again.

who I wanted to go home did! (sorry DBack, no hard feelings right?) I'm getting sick of Brook and her pouty faces she makes when she's getting critiqued, granted the hamburger w/o the meat was a little weird, but her facial expressions drive me nutty and her song choices haven't been doing it for me. I thought David Cook was awesome! At first when he started I didn't know, but by the end, go David!

Originally Posted by Shann

weird I replied to this earlier this morning but my reply isn't here well here it is again.

who I wanted to go home did! (sorry DBack, no hard feelings right?) I'm getting sick of Brook and her pouty faces she makes when she's getting critiqued, granted the hamburger w/o the meat was a little weird, but her facial expressions drive me nutty and her song choices haven't been doing it for me. I thought David Cook was awesome! At first when he started I didn't know, but by the end, go David!

Me too, I was not sure about him, but each week he surprises me! He should definately win! The other David is getting on my nerves...I really want Syesha to go next! I am tired of David A's same crap every week too,lol...

yeah I am ready for Jason, and David A to go. 2 things that bug me about David A. is 1) his song choices are always w/ a social message. He is 17 and I would like him to seem young at least once. and 2) his "surprise" when they have good things to say looks coached. It may not be but it comes across that way. Syesha also needs to go. She is talented but doesn't do it for me. Dh likes Brook and I do too, usually. David C. I really like.

I know it was from last week but any one else not impressed w/ Maria? She seemed fake and arrogant under the guise of trying to be non self centered (does that make any sense?)


Last nights random thoughts:
*Saisha - finally brought it, did great!
*Jason - if you knew you were picking a song from a musical maybe you should have gotten some back ground on the song you were going to sing. he bored me last night
*Carley - a little yellie at parts but really good! good choice for her.
*Brooke - got un-nerved when she messed up, did ok but not as good as she could have
*David A. - great job as usual.
*David C. - guess he wanted to show a ballad side but I think there were a lot more choices that would have worked a little better for him.

I absolutely LOVE Andrew Lloyd Weber! So I loved last nights episode and drove my kids crazy this am playing songs on youtube!

Originally Posted by ladybugmo

I know it was from last week but any one else not impressed w/ Maria? She seemed fake and arrogant under the guise of trying to be non self centered (does that make any sense?)


Last nights random thoughts:
*Saisha - finally brought it, did great!
*Jason - if you knew you were picking a song from a musical maybe you should have gotten some back ground on the song you were going to sing. he bored me last night
*Carley - a little yellie at parts but really good! good choice for her.
*Brooke - got un-nerved when she messed up, did ok but not as good as she could have
*David A. - great job as usual.
*David C. - guess he wanted to show a ballad side but I think there were a lot more choices that would have worked a little better for him.

I agree with all of that except David C.. he did a fabulous job on that song... I love The Phantom of the Opera..and he blew that song away...

I am so scared for tonight. I absolutely adore Carly and I think she did wonderful (even Simon liked her) but DialIdol shows her with the least votes, followed by Brooke and then Jason. They are not always right so I am keeping my fingers crossed that its Jason...lol